《全民造星》EP 37 - A3黑馬陣容鬥B3地球最強
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 мар 2025
- A2組及B2組完成跳舞項目比拼，賽場台前幕後對賽果摒息以待。剩餘下來既比賽隊伍能否擺脫夢魘，重整旗鼓擦亮招牌成為眾人焦點。30強賽事接近尾聲，廠內彌漫淚眶泣聲與不捨之情。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
網絡平台 : viu.tv
IG: viutv
RUclips: bit.ly/2a8lbLu
App:
IOS-apple.co/2NJo9Iw
Andriod - bit.ly/2LCVG9U
8:03 Frankie每滴眼淚100分
估不到這集是Ellen （盧凱彤）最後一次在銀幕上出現，她在這集後的第二天跳樓，真是可惜。😢她真是一個才女，為音樂作出很多美妙的作品，同時也很有眼光，lAN 和 肥仔都在這節目中㸃名讚賞。到四年後的今天他們給娛樂事業發光發熱，lAN和肥仔你們的努力有人睇到的。不要給腐文影響到自己的心情。加油💪
Her comment is so insightful too. Never knew much about her but now i feel sad that she's gone even just after 1 video.
(These 5 judges are so much better than the last 5 at least. but that's a different story)
其實Eric講得啱，哩行冇死刑嘅。當初B組係輸咗，但係之後mirror/error簽咗好多B組嘅人，佢地今日嘅發展亦都證明B組個個都值得。值得嘅人就會發光。
其實B組一開始成個勢都係大熱，所以啲所謂既導師，喺A組教緊表演既時候，佢地喺到教應答，做節目效果；喺A組搵埋老師黎教唱歌既時候，B組只係帶啲組員表面係做busking，實制上係pop佢首歌，事前又唔夾又唔盛，喺呢個成長系節目入面，B組既導師唔知教左佢地啲咩囉
登B組唔扺 😠
其實都係 火火比亞芝， 亞芝點同導演係教人表演方面比。側田同Eric kwok 應該其實厲害過劉美君 ，但劉美君厲害在有外援，有真唱歌老師，識唱歌都未必識教人。
想讚同 但又想補充.
我都覺得教應答 應該係成左星先要顧及. 但係, 我又覺得 好似 KT 咁 應答有對佢有幫助喎. 淨係幾十秒片段同佢加幾多人氣. 唔係net negative.
Busking 其實好好一個訓練. 教唱係實制, 但busking都有好多野學到....
不過最唔get 既係... 點解冇人知道 個 event 係學習唔係娛興? 節目 或 側田 溝通得唔好. B 隊唔識自已把握 花姐都鬧得佢地好啱
而且再講, 佢地 冇cut 片段出街者.... 你話B組完全 冇教唱 又好難相信喎.
如果已盡力，又如何要自責? 未盡力，又追究有何用? In this world 有很多事情系無論幾努力，你系不能控制，唯一可以做的是keep going keep doing keep trying!
個賽制真係有d問題，好多有實力的都反而無得留低😔太着重team battle
有冇留意到入咗行嗰d多數都係B組。錯敗是袋入袋嘅經歷,睇下16位幾紅。💪✌️
其實我都覺得肥仔嗰team overall 好睇啲～不過judges唔代表所有人
之前睇呢季時只掛住睇參賽者表演同評判反應，忽略咗好肉緊隊員嘅阿芝，同埋唔識做老師只係成日blame隊員嘅Eric Kwok。好奇點解第一季之後唔再搵黃心美拍強尼？佢兩個火花幾好，黃心美成日擺明芨仔個樣好好笑，加上好似佢今集咁真情流露，令個節目好好睇，Viu TV可在考慮搵返佢💪🏼
呢集真係印象超深刻 我諗十幾年後都唔會唔記得
3局一開始就2:0 然後第三局b組破釜沉舟 超班發揮
真係超感動
林奕匡番說話好鼓舞💪🏼
真係睇咗3次都完全睇唔到A2有啲乜嘢好過B2
唱歌係好D
啱啱番睇完。
我明白點解A2會贏個馬鼻。
因為B2唱果陣肥仔失手，皮皮就預咗佢失準，結果成隊靠嚴棋一個得分。
但A2叫做無失過手囉！
而咁唔好彩係B2跳舞贏嘅分數，抵唔番佢唱歌失嘅分數。
見到心美喊我都喊左 第一次睇心美 幾自然幾真性情 唔怪得喺ViuTV一姐
呢集拍得很好，好感動深刻！
林奕匡應該要出隻英文碟，佢唱All of me真係國際級，100分完全冇野可以挑剔，我相信就算係美國公開演唱依首歌都會全場standing ovation.
奇怪嘅係ellen俾comment時話A2唔算跳舞，咁跳舞battle唔係應該扣咗好多分咩？就算b2唱歌失手都唔應該輸俾放棄咗跳舞環節果組
Seems like all the judges look as it as it's just a singing contest. I don't think they value singing and dancing equally. The effort that dancers put for singing is no less than singers put for dancing. While the judges thinks the contestant should think what they could've done better, did the judges ask themselves if they'vd judged fairly?
Viutv 好野。節目效果一百分，重要係個個真到爆。
無得假 評判導師個個100分
評委係唔係有問題 揀明星又唔係諧星 咁鍾意entertaining 點解唔去睇棟篤笑 根本代表唔到大眾審美 憑乜代表大眾揀星
In memory of Ellen Loo
This is damn good tv
All group B cares for is Winning Winning Winning, but group A cares only about having fun together, growing together, and improving together...
isn’t that the point of a competition? sure u can have some fun moments to enjoy but isn’t winning more important than having some fun with your members? i’m sure you’d like to become an idol and a star rather than spend a few minutes having fun. That’s the reason they all came to this competition anyway ???
I don’t agree with the results!… ??? I don’t think team B deserved this!
到依家都唔明點解肥仔隊會輸😳😳⋯⋯
唱歌part走音 音準問題嚴重 後面做100分都唔夠cover
其實A 唱歌個part贏太多 A 個個唔唱得但係超班表現
B組D導師好明顯無去仔細執佢哋個表演。。。好多嘢都只係rehearsal嘅水準。。。以busking嘅表現，呀田有乜理由唔鬧佢哋。。。
輸嗰隊foul 10個超級唔公平。應該按各自嘅表現而决定
Good show
記得當年睇live，好鬼憎呢班評判😜
評審水準不足 只懂欣賞唱歌 不懂欣賞舞蹈 幾年前無睇全民造星 而家才番睇都還是為B组忿忿不平
完全認同
All the judges look as it as it's just a singing contest, and not valuing singing and dancing equally. The effort that dancers put for singing is no less than singers put for dancing. Sad.
其實呢局叫得用唱歌跳舞battle，放得唱歌人，都要放返一定跳舞人響評判團度balance，如果唔跳嚟把鬼咩。睇幾次都覺得B2輸得好唔抵
同埋輸咗就要foul 10個係一個好蠢嘅賽制。2組都係有好嘅有唔好嘅組員，而家入20强，仲要容許有d冇實力嘅人留低。3-7 咁分咗佢俾贏果組清吓淤血都好吖 （我估佢哋當時以為B組贏梗，你見大半隊mirror响B組就知）
lockman點解仲唔單飛 又靚仔 跳得 唱得
D裁判ON9，肥仔果隊點會輸
林奕匡講得好好
評判冇標準只睇評者喜好就冇公信力！
忍唔住又再留言，旁白講B組全部自責，我覺得除咗嚴棋，佢真係超乞人憎！又踩低人哋team又認為自己好掂，評判講得啱，不如睇下自己有乜做得唔夠好先啦！花姐話自己唔係偏心B組，我睇晒全部60集，都覺得全部人都係睇低A組！如果今日輸嘅係A組，我唔認為花姐會咁傷心囉！另外，全部人入面，我好欣賞龍志權，佢真係好有腦好有創意，佢啲表演我全部都好深刻！lokman，tiger,龍志權係我最鍾意嘅！
講中晒我心入面每個point。龍志權真係好正。嚴棋MK金毛肥，唱到咁就當自己歌神。
哩集喊到豬頭
友台永遠都冇可能超越viu😆！收皮啦TVB
Ellen 有眼光
8:05
宜家先知道 香港真係沉晒 質素差
評判🈚️水平
嚴褀應該係少有 求情時 踩人地team嘅
其實Bteam 最差就係佢 唱又冇乜特別
@Rayson 915 啱唔啱 見人見智啦 主觀嘢。 求情時間踩人係衰格
評審反而會睇到嚴祺唱得好好 但跳舞3位音準問題扣的分比較多 就算跳舞拎足100分都唔補。
我諗嚴褀都係唔甘心先咁⋯ 不過佢唱歌個part都冇發揮到應有既水準，加上可能評審見到佢個profile經驗咁多都唱得麻麻，都影響到個觀感